This question <33|33> overall <32|34> DrGuevara: <722|63>. (graded A)  
  Question 685: Are the productive powers part of the “economic structure” as defined here?   
  [33] DrGuevara: The Economic Structure.   The productive powers are not part of the “economic structure” as defined by Marx. This is because productive powers are not part of the relations of production. Relations of production according to Marx “constitutes the economic structure of society, the real basis . . .” The relations of production are the relations of the producers with the production process. Productive powers are both means of production and labor power. The means of production being the tools and machinery used in the production process and labor power being the skill of the workers in using productive equipment. Thus productive powers are not part of the economic basis but are what the economic basis rests on. An example is a computer. The ‘relations of production’ in this example are the computer. Its components interact so that the computer works, they constitute the structure of the computer. The electricity used to power the computer is not part of the computer but is the basis of the computer. In the same way one can say that tools, machinery, and labor keep the economic structure moving, but they are not part of a relation of production. We do not in a sense interact with the electricity of the computer but with the computer itself. We do however use the electricity. In another sense we do not interact with the hammer, we merely use it. We do interact with the project in which we are working on.   
  Hans: Good example, but in your original formulation you did not make it clear enough where you were talking about the computer example, and where about modes of production. In the archive copy I re-formulated this to make it clearer.   
 
 
 
  Students enrolled for Econ 5080 in 2009fa are invited to give feedback to the above message
Pseudonym:      UofU ID:  
Text: