This question <99|95> overall <90|92> Morgan: <693|292-4>.  
  Question 125: Why doesn't Marx say that the simplest value relation is that between commodity and money?   
  [91] Morgan: First we bartered, then we bought.   Marx does not refer to the relationship between commodity and money as the simplest form because it is not the simplest form. By simplest form Marx is referring to the most basic form, which is the first form, wherefrom all other forms originated. We need to keep in mind that his objective is to “trace the development of the form of value, to show the origin of money.” To do this Marx needs to identify the basic (original) form of assessing a value and then he will be able to find the origin of money.   
  Before we used a monetary system, we used the barter system. In this system items were traded and the commodities' value was assessed through the process of exchange. For example one may trade one cow for five chickens. In this instance the cow's value is equal to five chickens. This barter system did not require a neutral object (i.e. money) in order to function. Commodities were given value, based on their exchangeability with other commodities. This was the first way of forming value for a commodity. But the barter system had problems and because of these problems we progressed to the system of money. The problem was that people depended on others having what they needed and wanting what they had. If a man only had a mule to barter with and he needed flour, this meant someone needing a mule had to be willing to trade flour, otherwise the first man couldn't get what he needed. Due to this and other factors, we progressed into a monetary system. This clearly shows that money was not the simplest, meaning most basic or first, form of valuing a commodity.   
  Hans: We will see in chapter 2 that Marx's analysis of the problems of the barter system is different than the mainstream “double coincidence of wants” explanation.   
 
 
 
  Students enrolled for Econ 5080 in 2009fa are invited to give feedback to the above message
Pseudonym:      UofU ID:  
Text: