This question <173|201> overall <173|175> Hans: <171|176>.  
  Exam Question 28: Does the use-value of a commodity depend on the person using it?   
  [174] Hans: Does use-value depend on the user?   No, it doesn't. A thing has use-value if its properties are such that they are useful to humans. If Marx says that every commodity, in order to be exchangeable, must have use-value, he is thinking that it must be in principle usable, not that every single person will want to use it. If the question arises whether something is useful for a specific person, Marx uses the idiom “use-value for” that person, for instance he says that the commodity has no use-value for its producer. But without this “for,” use-values are independent of the individuals using the product.   
  This is all you need to say to answer this question in the exam.   
 
 
 
  Students enrolled for Econ 5080 in 2009fa are invited to give feedback to the above message
Pseudonym:      UofU ID:  
Text: