This question <34|39> overall <35|37> Stuart: <15|15>.  
  Question 74: Does Marx assume that only equal values are exchanged on the market?   
  [36] Stuart: I could be wrong but ...   I come to a different conclusion than Nogi [34]  
  Marx doesn't seem to believe that only equal values are exchanged on the market. Marx states that exchange proportions constantly change with time and place. However Marx never says that exchange values themselves constantly change but instead the exchange proportions. Marx seems to be addressing price volatility. External forces may cause the price of a commodity to be set below or above its exchange value. My understanding is that the Labor Theory of Value states that these discrepancies between prices and exchange-values of a commodity average out to be equal in the end. This is significant because if this is true then profits are not a result of pricing commodities above their values, but instead must come from somewhere else.   
 
 
 
  Students enrolled for Econ 5080 in 2009fa are invited to give feedback to the above message
Pseudonym:      UofU ID:  
Text: