This question <85|98> overall <88|90> Desk: <529|252>.  
  Question 223: Describe the joint work of all commodities which is necessary to appropriately express the value of one commodity.   
  [89] Desk: The Value of a Commodity.   When I look at the definition of commodity according to Marx I see that a commodity is something for which there is demand, but which is supplied without qualitative differentiation across a given market. Every commodity has a certain value attached to it which requires work at a given point. That is where the joint work of all commodities comes into play when you express the value of one commodity. Thomas Cooper explained something great with one simple phrase “Take away from a piece of bread the labor bestowed by the baker on the flour, by the miller on the grain brought to him, by the farmer in plowing, sowing, tending, gathering, threshing, cleaning and transporting the seed, and what will remain? A few grains of grass, growing wild in the woods, and unfit for any human purpose.” This statement describes perfectly what is meant by the joint work of all commodities which is necessary to express the value of one commodity. Marx explains that all commodities express values in the General equivalent, this general equivalent commodity is directly exchangeable with all commodities. If you take an ordinary commodity to market, two questions must be resolved for a change to go through: (1) does your trading partner need your commodity and (2) how much of his own commodity is he going to give you for your commodity. (159:2) In the case of this piece of bread, everyone is reliant on every one's commodity, the trade must take place. There will be shared values given to reap the reward in the end. This also is why you will pay more for the one commodity (bread) while you do not see the joint work that takes place to make it possible.   
  Hans: You are saying several loosely related things in your answer, but the right answer to question 223 is not among them. Look at [2005fa:815] for instance.   
 
 
 
  Students enrolled for Econ 5080 in 2008fa are invited to give feedback to the above message
Pseudonym:      UofU ID:  
Text: